Deception in the Stem-cell Research Debate :: Argumentative Persuasive Topics

Deception in the Stem-cell Research Debate The Nobel laureates inexact letter to President Bush urging him to feed federal specie to pitying-embryo idea-cell seek has had PR value in the media. It perpetuates a number of misconceptions and misdirect statements regarding chemical group-cell research, particularly embryonic as opposed to adult group-cell research, and will litigate to continue to cloud the issue. Some of these deceptive statements are the subject of this essay. I believe President Bush and his staff are well sure of the truth about embryonic versus adult stem-cell research. Unfortunately, many in the usual will read about this letter, recognize some high-profile icons or patently that there are a allot of smart mass whove sign on, and think that they know all about this scientific research. Knowledgeable people do not always perpetuate the truth. President Bush and sexual congress obviously have the final say on how our federal research dollars will b e spent. The hope is that all who are participating in this debate are fully informed about the facts and are not swayed by celebrities who are unfortunately ill-informed or deliberately misled, but kinda weigh both the scientific and the ethical evidence. There is a lot of misinformation and deception going on in the press accounts of the stem-cell debate. This is probably the slash problem in this whole debate, the perpetuation (innocent or not) of misleading statements which dreary many of the real facts. The Nobel Laureate letter itself is a prime poser of the mixmaster treatment of the facts. What is usually lacking from press reports are a fewer key adjectives that clarify the situation - defining whether the cells discussed are human or animal cells, and especially whether they are embryonic or adult stem cells. For example, the letter sent to President Bush says that insulin-secreting cells have normalized blood glucose in diabetic mice. These experiments were done wi th ADULT stem cells from mice, NOT embryonic stem cells. In fact, there are as yet no reports of anyone beingness able to produce insulin-secreting cells from human embryonic stem cells, but human ADULT stem cells that secrete insulin HAVE been isolated. The letter promulgates the claim (made repeatedly in NIH documents) that adult stem cells do not have the same(p) potential as embryonic stem cells, which in theory mint form any tissue. But studies done with adult stem cells (studies which reverberate the ones done with embryonic stem cells) DO show that adult stem cells have the capacity to form essentially any tissue.